If you’ve been paying attention, then you’ll know that the NYC housing market is in a fully-fledged buyer’s market. Sellers have slowly come around to the conclusion that they have to reduce asking prices if they are to stay competitive. With the current and future glut in inventory, they have little choice other than taking their properties off the market.
But if you’re looking to buy during this golden opportunity, there might be a better option then trying to haggle a seller down to their final offer. Rather than focusing just on the sales price, you should be negotiating closing costs as well. Sellers tend to be far more open to concessions such as these then steep price cuts alone.
However, not all closing costs are fair game for negotiation. It would be considered very unreasonable for a buyer to expect a seller to pay for their application fee just as it would be for a seller to ask a buyer to pay their move-out fee. The type and condition of property up for sale will also determine how open the seller is to concessions.
Table of Contents
Closing costs that are the most open for negotiation
The easiest closing costs to negotiate are the flip-taxes and transfer taxes. In a hot market, sellers will aim to make buyers pay these. In a slow market as we have now it’s the other way around.
Look to new developments for the most concessions
The best opportunities for reducing closing costs is with new developments. The reason is that with so many new developments on the rise, developers are eager to get inventory into a contract. However, they don’t want to reduce their asking price. With an oversupply of inventory and fewer buyers in the market to compete with, savvy buyers can negotiate for concessions.
The first one to aim for is the transfer tax, which stands at 1.425% of the purchase price (for properties priced at $500,000 or over). In a resale transaction, this fee is usually covered by the seller. But in a new development purchase, it switches to the buyer’s responsibility. In the current market with new developments struggling, especially on the luxury side, developers are now more willing to take up this charge.
Don’t overlook either the NYS transfer tax which is $4 per $1,000 of the purchase price. Some sponsors are even willing to cover months or even years in common charges. With things as they are now, other smaller fees are also potentially up for negotiation. These include the working capital fund contribution and the fee to cover the buyer’s share of the resident managers unit and sponsor’s attorney fees
Negotiate for closing credits
Instead of negotiating for price reductions, negotiate for closing credits. This money can then go directly towards paying off some of your remaining closing costs. Consider the difference between a $10,000 reduction in the sales price and $10,000 in closing credits.
The reduction in the sales price will only offset your mortgage payments by a slight margin. But the closing credits mean that’s $10,000 less you’ll have to draw out of your bank account at closing.